[env-trinity] Grape and nut drying up Golden State's water holes
Dan Bacher
danielbacher at fishsniffer.com
Tue May 3 18:09:29 PDT 2016
http://patrickporgansblog.blogspot.com/2016/05/grape-and-nut-glut-drying-up-golden.html
Grape and nut glut drying up Golden State’s watering holes Part I
California water officials and mainstream media assertions this epic
drought caused socioeconomic and financial disaster to state’s economy
is not supported by the facts published in government reports.
Three years into the drought and the Golden State Gross Domestic
Product (GDP) reached a record of $2.31 trillion, agricultural
revenues higher than ever, statewide building permits doubled, and
more water-guzzling permanent crops planted. (Latest published GDP
figures.)
IMMEDIATE RELEASE: 2 May 2016
Contact Patrick Porgans, Solutionist Porgans/Associates porgansinc at sbcglobal.net
(916) 833-8734
Californians inundated by a plethora of mainstream-media bytes
predicting Draconian consequence from this "epic drought" water
experts and public-relations firms branded the worst in 500-years are
perplexed by drought-flood news accounts aired simultaneously.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/01/30/california-drought-effects-500-years_n_4647539.html
Meanwhile, government officials, water contractors, and mainstream
media, whine about the dire impacts of the so-called worst drought in
California since the 1500s, the record, show they're reaping windfall
profits.
Public records attest that the Golden State's economy, tax revenue
stream, and Gross Domestic Product (GDP) reached all-time highs during
four years of drought. In the third year of the drought, the state's
GDP was a record-breaker.
"In 2014, the State’s GDP was ranked as the 7th or 8th largest economy
in the world, based on traditional measurements [just below France and
above Brazil]. On June 10 [2015], the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis
released its preliminary estimates of state gross domestic product
(GDP) for 2014, as we described in a blog post last week. California's
2014 GDP— the value of all goods and services produced here—was
estimated at $2.31 trillion. There are different estimates of
countries' GDP."http://www.lao.ca.gov/LAOEconTax/Article/Detail/90
That number is the latest number published by the government (www.bea.gov
)
Epic drought generates the largest budget in State’s history: Last
month, Governor Jerry Brown proposed the largest budget in
California's history; $170 billion, of which, $120 billion comes from
the State's General Fund revenue stream; with additional billions
earmarked by Brown to the "Rainy Day" fund. This surplus of funds is
collected tax revenue; almost 70 percent of the $120 billion is
derived from personal income tax. Today, the Rainy Day Fund is at 37
percent of its constitutional target (10 percent of General Fund tax
revenues) amounts to $12 billion to be held in reserve! The Budget
proposes to bring the Rainy Day Fund to a balance of 65 percent. ttp://
ebudget.ca.gov/FullBudgetSummary.pdf]
This March, government and water industry officials responded to the
good news by extending mandatory water cutback! California’s economy
has expanded during the past seven years.
Governor’s Budget Summary 2016-2017, Introduction. "The economy is
finishing its seventh year of expansion, already two years longer than
the average recovery. While the timing is uncertain, the next
recession is getting closer, and the state must begin to plan for it.
If new ongoing commitments are made now, then the severity of the cuts
will be far greater – even devastating – when the recession begins.
Without question, the best way to protect against future cuts is to
build up the state’s Rainy Day Fund," according to Gov. Brown.
Californians face a multi-dimensional conundrum; an extended drought,
which imposed first-time ever statewide mandatory water cutbacks while
portions of the state are under siege from flooding resulting from the
remnant of a fading El Nino. Factors compounded by a massive appeal by
the water industry requesting State Water Resources Control Board
(SWRCB) members to end the drought. In the interim, the Brown
Administration recently reinstituted signage posted on California
highways stating: Extreme Drought – Conserve water!
Water condition above average: The truth about the state's water
conditions is immersed in a stupor of shifting forecasts, as is the
winter weather, unpredictable and changing. On 1 February a report
depicting statewide precipitation at 115 percent and 120 percent for
the North Coast Region for this time of year, according to Department
of Water Resources (DWR) personnel.1 The very next day 2 February the
SWRCB voted to extend drought emergency regulation, purportedly to
ensure mandatory water conservation through October 2016.2
http://saveourwater.com/blog-posts/conservation-extended/
In early March through April Californians were stunned as officials
dump floodwaters from Folsom Dam, on the American River, which had
received 120 percent of average precipitation. Water was also being
dumped at other major reservoirs in the north state.http://www.sacbee.com/news/state/california/water-and-drought/article67772672.html
It is estimated that more than one million acre-feet of water were
dumped from state reservoirs, enough to provide half of the water
needs of those 19 million customers receive annually from the
Metropolitan Water District of Southern California.
The March snow survey, conducted by DWR personnel showed snowpack at
locations ranged from low 90s to over 100 percent of average. http://www.water.ca.gov/waterconditions/waterconditions.cfm
Findings contained in a Forensic Accounting based on the public record
and direct intercommunication with water officials and regulatory
personnel, most of whom putatively accepted the 500-year conjecture,
in the absences of verifiable peer-reviewed data. If the intrinsic
shortcomings of those assertions were even theoretically plausible,
assuming that this is the worst drought in California, it might have
possibly occurred in central and southern California; however, the
public record does not support those assertions in the water-rich
north state. http://www.theterranews.com/content/?p=66539
Forensic Accounts of previous drought events are the subject of a
series of article that prompted responses from the California Farm
Water Coalition.
The California Farm Water Coalition has this response to Patrick
Porgans & Lloyd Carter’s post, Wolf Cries – Howling About Drought –
All Wet – No More Doubts Officials Exaggerated Severity of Drought:
"Coalition viewpoint…These numbers provide a clear picture of the
effect that governmental regulations and the drought, during the past
four years, had on water users who rely on deliveries of water through
the Delta. As indicated by the bloggers, the water years in the
Sacramento Valley from 2006-2009 averaged 16.39 million acre-feet
(MAF), which is a 60% increase, or 6 MAF more than during 1989-1992." http://www.farmwater.org/Current-News/
http://www.watereducation.org/aquafornia-news/california-farm-water-coalition-responds-porganscarter-commentary-howling-about
Ironically, the doomsday public-relations campaign precipitated an
astonishing downpour of wealth to state and federal water contractors
that already receive publicly-subsidized water. Water districts and
land-gentry billionaires reaped an abundant harvest of public give-
away funds. Unfortunately, their profits come at the expense and to
the demise of urban water users; taxpayers, the state General Fund,
and Public Trust Resources (water, fish, and wildlife).3
Abundant Harvest: Contrary to mainstream media reports, agricultural
profits reached all-time high in the fourth year of drought. "Even
though the 2014 crop year coincides with the third consecutive year of
unprecedented drought, the innovation and resilience of California’s
agricultural community continue to ensure the State’s agricultural
abundance. Despite the tremendous challenges in 2014, the farmgate
value of the state’s 76,400 farms and ranches was a record $54
billion. Of the $54 billion, over $21 billion was attributed to
California’s agricultural exports." http://cdec.water.ca.gov/cgi-progs/iodir?s=b120
Building permits doubled: In the second and third year of the drought,
building permits doubled statewide.
http://www/census.gpv/construction/bps/txt/tb2u2013.txt http://www/census.gpv/construction/bps/txt/tb2u2012.txt
http://www.dof.ca.gov/HTML/FS_DATA/LatestEconData?FS_Construction.htm
The Governor's Proclamation and the Emergency Drought Regulations
relieve government water project operators of their obligation to
comply with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act
(CEQA). It also sanctions the reduction or suspension of water quality
standards and objectives contained in the San Francisco Bay-
Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta Estuary Water Quality Control Plan;
enacted to protect Delta farmers, water diverters, and aquatic, avian
and terrestrial species.
The SWRCB issued emergency drought regulation that targets mandatory
cutbacks by urban-residential users, while subversively exempting the
agricultural industry that reportedly applies an estimated 80 percent
of the state's developed water supply annually. Instead, Board members
left it up to the agricultural industry to reduce and conserve water.
Gross agricultural revenues represent about two (2) percent of the
State's GDP. Additional revenue is generated by the processing and
distribution of the products produced. Thus for every dollar of value
added in that sector, there is an additional $1.27 added to the state
economy.
http://aic.ucdavis.edu/publications/moca/moca_current/moca09/moca09chapter5.pdf
During this current drought, it is estimated that $3 billion of
borrowed public funds have already been given away for drought
"relief" programs. That money comes from the sale of State issued
General Obligation (G.O.) bonds, which, repayment is backed by the
full-faith and credit of California. A list of General Obligation
Bonds authorized and issued by the state can be found here.http://www.treasurer.ca.gov/bonds/debt/04/authorized.pdf
For every dollar of G.O. bonds sold, it cost a dollar in interest; it
will cost $6 billion to repay, with revenues derived the State's
General Fund. "It must never be forgotten, however, that 69.5 percent
of our General Fund revenues come from the volatile personal income
tax which, as history shows us, drops precipitously in time of
recession — an event not too far off given the historic pattern of the
ten recessions that have occurred since 1945. During a moderate
recession, revenue losses to the General Fund will easily total $55
billion over three years"; Gov.'s Budget Summary 2016-2017.11 [Note:
Rainy Day Fund is used to assure bond investors G.O. debt is covered. http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-sac-jerry-brown-releases-state-budget-20160107-story.html
California land of fruits and nuts exporting water to foreign markets
"California, which produces much of the country's water-guzzling
fruits [nuts] and vegetables, is in year four of a major drought, and
almonds, its No. 1 export, have become a symbol of the state's heavy
water consumption. Mature almond trees in the Southern Sacramento
Valley use 41 to 44 inches of water on average per year, according to
the University of California at Davis. Trees in drier southern San
Joaquin Valley use 50 to 54 inches. In California, an acre supports
about 124 almond trees. Last year, and acre produced around 2,270
pounds of almonds, for a ratio of about 502 gallons of water per pound
of nuts." (The math works out to equals 3.49 acre-feet of water per
acre of almonds planted.) Total amount of water applied averages out
to 3.55 MAF annually.
www.wsj.com/articles/the-numbers-behind-agricultural-water-use-1434726353
The amount of water required to sustain the growth of these almonds is
1.4 MAF more than the 2.1 MAF the Metropolitan Water District (MWD) of
Southern California provides annually. (One acre-foot equals about
326,000 gallons; an average California household uses between one-half
and one acre-foot of water per year for indoor and outdoor use.)http://www.watereducation.org/general-information/whats-acre-foot
Almond crop bonanza – money grows on trees: In the year 2000, there
was 610,000 acre of almond planted, valued at $666,487,000 for the
crop. California's 2014 almond acreage is estimated at 1,020,000
acres, up 5 percent from the 2013 acreage of 970,000, according to a
recent survey conducted by the National Agricultural Statistics
Service. Of the total acreage for 2014, 870,000 acres were bearing,
and 150,000 acres were nonbearing, crop valued at $6,464,500,000.http://www.nass.usda.gov/Statistics_by_StateCalifornia/Publications/fruits_and_Nuts/201505almpd.pdf
The subjective production for the 2015 almond crop is 1.85 billion
pounds, according to a survey conducted by the National Statistic
Service. https://www.nass.usda.gov/Statistics_by_State/California/Publications/Fruits_and_Nuts/201505almpd.pdf
CBS and Fox News "erred" scenes of almond orchards ripped out due to a
lack of water while other experts predicted California would run out
of water in 2016. Public records do not support their assertions and
the orchard depicted in their stories failed to "air" the scene where
those same drought-stricken lands were replanted with a new variety of
almonds. http://www.cbsnews.com/news/depleting-the-water As indicated
by USDA's Graph California Almond Bearing Acreage has continued to
expand before and since the onset of this drought, in 2011.
http://www.nass.usda.gov/Statistics_by_State/California/Publications/Fruits_and_Nuts/201505almpd.pdf
The SWRCB was advised of almond acreage expansion years ago; it took
no action to curtail the use of the public's water, and growers went
nuts.http://www.waterboards.ca.gov/waterrightsissues/programs/drought/docs/workshops/comments/patrick_porgans.pdf
There was so much of a glut in the almond market that the price of
almonds dropped precipitously. After prices for almonds climbed to a
record $4 per pound in 2014, farmers across California began replacing
their cheaper crops with the nut, causing a huge increase in supply.
Now, the bubble has popped. Since late 2014, according to The
Washington Post, almond prices have fallen by around 25%.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/01/29/too-many-almonds/
More grapes and other permanent crops also planted while building
permits doubled statewide in 2013-2014.
http://www.dof.ca.gov/HTML/FS_DATA/LatestEconData/FS_Construction.htm
A major challenge facings taxpaying Californians, is if they can
afford to export water in the form of surplus fruits and nuts to
countries such as China, which is not required to pay an import tax.
In the interim, the California dream appears to be fading into the
midst impairing their quality of life and cost of living as the forces
behind water exploitation usurp others water and property rights.
Endnotes
1 California Department of Water Resources, Bulletin 120, Water
Conditions in California, February 1, 2016, p. 2.
2 State Water Resource Control Board’s Fact Sheet, Extending the
Emergency Water Conservation Regulation, 9 February 2016.
3 Joseph L. Sax, The Public Trust Doctrine In Natural Resource Law:
Effective Judicial Intervention, The Historical Background, Michigan
Law Review, [Vol. 68:471]
Part II: Water officials usurp property/water rights under the guise
drastic action to protect endangered fish
Part III: California’s drought-flood water management crises - why it
pays - source of funds
About the author: Patrick Porgans is a Solutionist, and for the past
40 years serving clients and as a de facto public trustee, assisting
and or compelling government officials to perform their functions in a
manner consistent with the law. Porgans authored more than 80 Fact-
Finding reports on water- and water-related issues in the West. He
contributed to Mark Reisner's Cadillac Desert publication. He is the
author of "Truth De-Code-It", which provides insight on how wealthy
land-gentry billionaires are using the tax base, the state's credit
rating, General Fund, General Obligation Bonds, and publicly-owned
natural resources to amass and sustain ill-gain fortunes. (Truth De-
Code-It focuses on ways to mutually coexist and to empower ourselves
to make change, one person, one day at a time. The FACT SHEET can be
viewed at www.planetarysolutionaries.org or by emailing noblewaters at yahoo.com
This report was made possible by the joint commitment of New-Old
Worlds Wholistically Emerging (NOWWE) and Patrick Porgans/Associates
as a public service. For more articles and FACT SHEETS, Google Patrick
Porgans water.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20160503/3dd3c76b/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Cawatercon.png
Type: image/png
Size: 97143 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20160503/3dd3c76b/attachment.png>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: almondgraph2015.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 16894 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20160503/3dd3c76b/attachment.jpg>
More information about the env-trinity
mailing list