[env-trinity] DWR Damage Control/Scientists renew criticism of tunnels documents

Wed Sep 16 10:20:59 PDT 2015

The Twin Tunnels Revised Draft EIS/EIR continues to fail to justify and adequately analyze this boondoggle.  The main points of criticism are in the Stockton Record article below along with the incredibly pathetic response by the California Resources Agency.

TS
http://blogs.esanjoaquin.com/san-joaquin-river-delta/2015/09/15/scientists-renew-criticism-of-tunnels-documents/

Scientists renew criticism of tunnels documents
By ALEX BREITLER | Published: SEPTEMBER 15, 2015 | Leave a commentUpdate: The Department of Water Resources has issued a statement in response to the Independent Science Board’s comments.Remember that pesky math teacher who kept insisting that you “show your work?”That’s essentially what the Delta Independent Science Board is telling proponents of Gov. Jerry Brown’s twin tunnels plan, in the scientists’ latest strong criticism of that effort.The scientists are not so much critiquing the project itself as they are the way in which the project is presented in complex environmental documents.A revised environmental impact report out for public comment right now is supposed to explain the rationale for building the tunnels, justify the proposal and outline the environmental impacts; instead, it “falls short as a basis for weighty decisions about natural resources,” the scientists found.They noted some improvement from a previous draft, but also quite a few problems, including:• The report is “marred by key gaps in information, analyses and summaries… The various gaps impede evaluation of the science that underpins the proposed project.” In other words, as my math teacher might’ve said, “Show your work.”• Details are lacking on how officials would adjust or change course if unexpected results occur (so-called “adaptive management”).• And on a related note, conclusions in the report contain an “exuberant display of optimism,” even though the 50-year timeframe for the project has been shortened considerably. There aren’t enough details on what actions will be taken in the “likely event that such optimism is unfulfilled.”• The report “offers no analysis of how levee failures would affect the short-term and long-term water operations…” Nor does the report give adequate consideration to climate change, sea level rise, future groundwater availability, the impacts of construction noise on sensitive birds like sandhill cranes, and the loss of Delta wetlands.• It is “unclear how (and how well) the fish screens would work.” This is a reference to the fish screens that would be built along the intakes at the northern end of the tunnels, to protect Sacramento River fish from the new diversions there. “Despite the lack of specific data on how well screens function, the conclusion that there will be no significant impact is stated as certain… Here, as in many other places, measures are assumed to function as planned, with no evidence to support the assumptions.”• The report lacks helpful summaries and graphics. “Far-reaching decisions about (the tunnels) should not hinge on environmental documents that few can grasp,” the scientists found.And, I might editorialize, if the Ph.D.s on the Delta Independent Science Board have difficulty understanding the environmental impact report, what chance do the rest of us have?- See more at: Scientists renew criticism of tunnels documents

|   |
|   |  |   |   |   |   |   |
| Scientists renew criticism of tunnels documentsUpdate: The Department of Water Resources has issued a statement in response to the Independent Science Board’s comments. Remember that pesky math teacher w... |
|  |
| View on blogs.esanjoaquin.com | Preview by Yahoo |
|  |
|   |

     On Wednesday, September 16, 2015 9:46 AM, CALIFORNIA NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY <info at BayDeltaConservationPlan.com> wrote:

  DWR Statement Regarding Delta Independent Science Board Comments on RDEIR/SDEIS#yiv2059953137 body, #yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137bodyTable, #yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137bodyCell{height:100% !important;margin:0;padding:0;width:100% !important;}#yiv2059953137 table{border-collapse:collapse;}#yiv2059953137 img, #yiv2059953137 a img{border:0;outline:none;text-decoration:none;}#yiv2059953137 h1, #yiv2059953137 h2, #yiv2059953137 h3, #yiv2059953137 h4, #yiv2059953137 h5, #yiv2059953137 h6{margin:0;padding:0;}#yiv2059953137 p{margin:1em 0;padding:0;}#yiv2059953137 a{word-wrap:break-word;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ReadMsgBody{width:100%;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass{width:100%;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass p, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass span, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass font, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass td, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137ExternalClass div{line-height:100%;}#yiv2059953137 table, #yiv2059953137 td{}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137outlook a{padding:0;}#yiv2059953137 img{}#yiv2059953137 body, #yiv2059953137 table, #yiv2059953137 td, #yiv2059953137 p, #yiv2059953137 a, #yiv2059953137 li, #yiv2059953137 blockquote{}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137bodyCell{padding:20px;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137mcnImage{vertical-align:bottom;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent img{height:auto !important;}#yiv2059953137 body, #yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137bodyTable{background-color:#e7e7e6;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137bodyCell{border-top:0;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137templateContainer{border:0;}#yiv2059953137 h1{color:#606060;display:block;font-family:'Lucida Sans Unicode', 'Lucida Grande', sans-serif;font-size:30px;font-style:normal;font-weight:normal;line-height:125%;letter-spacing:-1px;margin:0;text-align:center;}#yiv2059953137 h2{color:#606060;display:block;font-family:'Lucida Sans Unicode', 'Lucida Grande', sans-serif;font-size:26px;font-style:normal;font-weight:normal;line-height:125%;letter-spacing:-.75px;margin:0;text-align:center;}#yiv2059953137 h3{color:#46afd6;display:block;font-family:'Lucida Sans Unicode', 'Lucida Grande', sans-serif;font-size:18px;font-style:normal;font-weight:normal;line-height:200%;letter-spacing:-1px;margin:0;text-align:center;}#yiv2059953137 h4{color:#808080;display:block;font-family:'Lucida Sans Unicode', 'Lucida Grande', sans-serif;font-size:16px;font-style:normal;font-weight:normal;line-height:125%;letter-spacing:normal;margin:0;text-align:center;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137templatePreheader{background-color:#e7e7e6;border-top:0;border-bottom:0;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137preheaderContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137preheaderContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent p{color:#606060;font-family:Helvetica;font-size:11px;line-height:125%;text-align:left;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137preheaderContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent a{color:#606060;font-weight:normal;text-decoration:underline;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137templateHeader{background-color:#f4f3f2;border-top:0;border-bottom:0;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137headerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137headerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent p{color:#606060;font-family:Helvetica;font-size:9px;line-height:150%;text-align:left;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137headerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent a{color:#6DC6DD;font-weight:normal;text-decoration:underline;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137templateBody{background-color:#f4f3f2;border-top:0;border-bottom:0;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137bodyContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137bodyContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent p{color:#606060;font-family:Arial, 'Helvetica Neue', Helvetica, sans-serif;font-size:13px;line-height:150%;text-align:left;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137bodyContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent a{color:#24647f;font-weight:normal;text-decoration:underline;}#yiv2059953137 #yiv2059953137templateFooter{background-color:#2d2d2d;border-top:0;border-bottom:0;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137footerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent, #yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137footerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent p{color:#606060;font-family:Helvetica;font-size:10px;line-height:125%;text-align:center;}#yiv2059953137 .yiv2059953137footerContainer .yiv2059953137mcnTextContent a{color:#606060;font-weight:normal;text-decoration:underline;}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 body, #yiv2059953137 table, #yiv2059953137 td, #yiv2059953137 p, #yiv2059953137 a, #yiv2059953137 li, #yiv2059953137 blockquote{}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 body{width:100% !important;min-width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[id=yiv2059953137bodyCell]{padding:10px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContentContainer]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnBoxedTextContentContainer]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcpreview-image-uploader]{width:100% !important;display:none;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 img[class=yiv2059953137mcnImage]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageGroupContentContainer]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageGroupContent]{padding:9px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageGroupBlockInner]{padding-bottom:0 !important;padding-top:0 !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 tbody[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageGroupBlockOuter]{padding-bottom:9px !important;padding-top:9px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnCaptionBottomContent]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardRightTextContentContainer]{width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardRightImageContent]{padding-right:18px !important;padding-left:18px !important;padding-bottom:0 !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardBottomImageContent]{padding-bottom:9px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardTopImageContent]{padding-top:18px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardRightImageContent]{padding-right:18px !important;padding-left:18px !important;padding-bottom:0 !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardBottomImageContent]{padding-bottom:9px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnImageCardTopImageContent]{padding-top:18px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table[class=yiv2059953137mcnCaptionRightContentOuter] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent]{padding-top:9px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnCaptionBlockInner] table[class=yiv2059953137mcnCaptionTopContent]:last-child td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent]{padding-top:18px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnBoxedTextContentColumn]{padding-left:18px !important;padding-right:18px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent]{padding-right:18px !important;padding-left:18px !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 table[id=yiv2059953137templateFooter]{max-width:600px !important;width:100% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 h1{font-size:24px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 h2{font-size:20px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 h3{font-size:18px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 h4{font-size:16px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137mcnBoxedTextContentContainer] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent] p{font-size:18px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 table[id=yiv2059953137templatePreheader]{display:block;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137preheaderContainer] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent] p{font-size:14px !important;line-height:115% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137headerContainer] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent] p{font-size:18px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137bodyContainer] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent] p{font-size:18px !important;line-height:125% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td .filtered99999 td .filtered99999 , #yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137footerContainer] td[class=yiv2059953137mcnTextContent] p{font-size:14px !important;line-height:115% !important;}}@media screen and (max-width:480px){#yiv2059953137 td[class=yiv2059953137footerContainer] a[class=yiv2059953137utilityLink]{display:block;}}  
|  
|  
| 
|  
|      |

  |

 |

  |
|  
| 
|  
|    |

  |

|  
|    |

  |

 |

  |
|  
| 
|  
|  
September 16, 2015

DWR Statement Regarding Delta Independent Science Board Comments on RDEIR/SDEIS
___________________________________Statement from Cassandra Enos-Nobriga, program manager for the California Department of Water Resources, about the Delta Independent Science Board comments on the Partially Recirculated Draft Environmental Impact Report/Supplemental Draft Environmental Impact Statement (RDEIR/SDEIS) for California WaterFix:

The Department of Water Resources is grateful for the Independent Science Board (ISB) review of the California WaterFix/Bay Delta Conservation Plan RDEIR/SDEIS.  The ISB’s comments will help ensure the state's approach to protecting the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta uses the best possible scientific methods, coordination and inquiry.  The ISB’s specific comments on various resource chapters of the RDEIR/SDEIS will enhance analysis of the proposed project by DWR and the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation and improve the final environmental impact documents.

The ISB found much to laud in the new documents, including for example that:   
   - The new Sections 1 through 4 are well-written;
   - Section 2 provides the great service of summarizing how the previous draft was revised in response to project changes and public input;
   - Section 4 presents an impressive amount of detailed information; and
   - if the comprehensive "Resource Restoration and Performance Principles" listed in the environmental documents are adhered to, the project should have minimal impacts on biological resources that might be affected by construction or operations.
Several of the ISB’s comments warrant clarification.   
   - In developing California WaterFix, three new alternatives were added to the existing 15 already being considered to meet the project objectives and purpose and need. The primary change with the RDEIR/SDEIS is that there is a different proposed project (preferred alternative). The California WaterFix does not have a 15-year time period as stated in the ISB comments.    

   - The 21 other conservation measures in the Bay Delta Conservation Plan are part of the alternatives that include a Habitat Conservation Plan/Natural Community Conservation Plan (HCP/NCCP).  A portion of many of the conservation measures also would serve as mitigation to offset construction related impacts, including construction of the conveyance project.  Elements of the conservation measures, including restoration, that offset construction related impacts remain as part of the proposed California WaterFix project and non-HCP/NCCP alternatives.  Other conservation measures that make up the HCP/NCCP alternatives will be or are being pursued through other projects and programs at the state, federal or local level.    

   - Some comments of the Delta ISB relate to issues beyond the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) and National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and beyond the scope of an EIR/EIS.  The purpose of an EIR/EIS is to identify and evaluate the potential impacts of a project on the existing environment.  The major focus of the CEQA/NEPA environmental review requirement directs the lead agency to focus on how construction and operation of the proposed project would adversely impact existing resources. CEQA and NEPA do not direct an agency, beyond a cumulative impact analysis, to specifically analyze how other future actions, unrelated to the proposed project, also could affect the environment.  So, for example, while DWR appreciates the importance of understanding the viability of future levee programs and the environmental effect of levee failure, such an assessment falls outside the scope of CEQA and NEPA requirements and instead would occur as a part of a feasibility study related to engineering design.   

   - An EIR/EIS should not be speculative.  CEQA specifically directs an agency not to speculate and to terminate discussion of an impact where it is too speculative for evaluation.  However, for example, the ISB reviewers state that they would like to see in the draft environmental review documents greater detail about the effects of changed water availability on agricultural practices in the San Joaquin Valley.  Although some degree of forecasting may be appropriate in certain situations where the indirect actions are reasonably certain to occur, such speculation in this instance would not be reasonably foreseeable and therefore inappropriate in an EIR/EIS.   

   - To a large extent, CEQA and NEPA direct that an EIR/EIS follow a certain format related to defining the environmental setting/affected environment and then sequentially analyzing impacts of how the proposed action would cause potentially significant impacts to that existing environment.  The environmental setting should be focused on the physical conditions which exist within the area and will be affected by the project.  This area is limited to only that where significant impacts would occur.  While the ISB reviewers state that they would like to see greater detail on a “landscape” level, an EIR/EIS does not call for such an analysis. The state, however, is working to improve its landscape-level understanding of resource management.  Similarly, efforts are underway to better articulate how the California EcoRestore program will be properly and effectively coordinated with other restoration programs.   

   - The ISB reviewers state that they would like to see more detail on adaptive management.  An EIR/EIS is required to present all feasible mitigation to avoid or substantially reduce potentially significant impacts and develop a monitoring program for the implementation of the mitigation that is required.  Where the mitigation relies on the future development of a detailed plan, performance standards must be included within the measure’s description; however, comprehensive adaptive management programs are not necessarily a specific element of that mitigation plan.  An EIR/EIS does not call for a comprehensive summary of adaptive management principles.  Nonetheless, DWR puts adaptive management into practice on a regular basis and will continue to do so for any future project.    

   - The ISB expresses interest in greater detail.  But an EIR/EIS should not be judged as a comprehensive treatise on Delta challenges or even a primer for policy makers.  It is one piece of the overall panoply of information to be utilized in decision-making, and its boundaries are narrowly prescribed by law.
We welcome the Delta ISB's interest in how the State intends to manage water supplies and protect invaluable natural resources in the Delta, and we hope to continue working collaboratively with both the ISB and the Delta Stewardship Council toward that goal.

   |

  |

|  
|  
|  
|  
|  
|  
|    |

  |

  |

|  
|  
|    |

  |

  |

|  
|  
|    |

  |

  |

  |

  |

  |

  |

 |

  |
|  
| 
|  
|      |

  |

|  
|  CALIFORNIA NATURAL RESOURCES AGENCY
CONTACT US | 866.924.9955 | CALIFORNIAWATERFIX.COM
CALIFORNIA WATER FIX IS ALTERNATIVE 4A | © 2010-2015 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

unsubscribe from this list    update subscription preferences   |

  |

 |

  |

  |

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150916/b7456ee6/attachment.html>