[env-trinity] Article submission: Water board chief admits he was 'just wrong’

[Dan Bacher]

"He admitted he was wrong last year in assessing the impacts to fish -  
and so now he is proposing to do it again," said Bill Jennings,  
Executive Director of the California Sportfishing Protection Alliance  
(CSPA).

cspa_jennings_tucp_presentation.pdf
download PDF (353.0 KB)

Water board chief admits he was 'just wrong’
by Dan Bacher
It is rare when a public official admits when he/she does something  
wrong. It's even rarer when a state water official serving the  
administration of Governor Jerry Brown admits they did something wrong.

But that's exactly what happened in Sacramento on Wednesday, February  
18, when Tom Howard, executive director of the State Water Resources  
Control Board (SWRCB), the controversial agency overseeing California  
water, claimed he was “mistaken” last year when he approved emergency  
actions that harmed imperiled Delta smelt, Sacramento River winter-run  
Chinook salmon and other fish species.

"At a 12-hour hearing in Sacramento on Wednesday, Tom Howard,  
executive officer of the State Water Resources Control Board, made  
clear the impact of the severe drought on people," according to Alex  
Breitler in the Stockton Record on February 19. (http://www.recordnet.com/article/20150219/NEWS/150219563 
)

"But he also said he was 'just wrong' when he concluded last year that  
temporarily changing the rules to keep more water in reservoirs would  
not cause unreasonable harm to the environment. Despite that  
admission, Howard approved many of the same emergency changes this  
year, such as reducing flows through the Delta to hold back more water  
in upstream reservoirs," Breitler said.

"He denied, however, a request by state and federal water agencies to  
also increase water exports from the south Delta under certain  
conditions. Wednesday’s meeting was to gather comments on that  
decision and other aspects of the emergency rule changes," noted  
Breitler.

Bill Jennings, Executive Director of the California Sportfishing  
Protection Alliance (CSPA), responded to the water official's "mea  
culpa" by pointing out the hypocrisy of Howard making his admission  
while proposing to do the same thing again.

"He admitted he was wrong last year in assessing the impacts to fish -  
and so now he is proposing to do it again," said Jennings.

In his presentation to the water board, Jennings pointed out how the  
water board's decisions in 2013 and 2014 have brought Delta smelt and  
other fish species to the edge of extinction. (http://www.indybay.org/uploads/2015/02/21/cspa_jennings_tucp_presentation.pdf 
)

"In early 2013, we predicted what would happen if the Board failed to  
enforce standards," said Jennings. "The result? In the fall midwater  
trawl survey, Delta smelt abundance dropped by 57%, striped bass by  
44%, and salmon were hammered."

"In early 2014, we predicted what would happen if you adopted the TUCP  
(Temporary Urgency Change Petition)," Jennings told the board. "The  
result? Delta smelt dropped another 50% (and the spring Kodiak survey  
by 84%) longfin smelt dropped by 90%, and 95% percent of the winter- 
run Chinook salmon were killed."

"Today, we're telling you that, if the TUCP is adopted, disaster is  
likely as species may be pushed over the brink into a death-spiral of  
extinction," Jennings warned.	

Environmentalists, fishermen, Delta residents, water agency officials,  
growers and farmworkers packed the hearing room into the evening. A  
public comment period followed reports by agency and water board  
staff, elected officials and panels made up of growers, the Friant  
Water Authority users, the water contractors, San Joaquin County and  
Delta interests, and environmental NGOs.

Jennings spoke on the first environmental NGO panel including the  
California Sportfishing Protection Alliance (CSPA), California Water  
Impact Network (C-WIN), AquaAlliance and Restore the Delta.  
Representatives from the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and  
the Bay Institute spoke on the second environmental NGO panel.

The board made no decision at the hearing, since its purpose was to  
gather information and public comment to advise issuing an order.  
Board members indicated at the end of the hearing that they wanted  
more information before issuing an order, perhaps in March.

For complete coverage of the hearing, go to: http://us3.campaign-archive2.com/?u=06887fa70084fef8e939fef63&id=9201e548e3&e=120d0c2b69

Fishermen, Delta leaders protest plan to exterminate salmon

On Tuesday afternoon, Delta fishermen and community leaders held a  
news conference outside the State Water Resources Control Board  
meeting and announced they have filed protests against the Board for  
its January 27, 2015 Notice of Temporary Change Petitions (TUCP). They  
said granting the petitions will weaken Delta outflow and water  
quality standards to the point of extinction for Delta smelt and  
winter-run Chinook salmon this year.

You can listen to an audio of the conference at: http://bit.ly/1L8cnyB

Barbara Barrigan-Parrilla, Executive Director of Restore the Delta,  
said, “The State Water Resources Control Board is in a difficult  
position. The Westlands Water District and other powerful agribusiness  
interests are pushing to press the Water Board into giving them every  
last drop of water during this drought."

"Senator Feinstein and the usual list of Central Valley Congressional  
Reps are using their Federal positions to intrude on issues that are  
supposed to be settled at the State level – all for the benefit of  
these growers in three of California’s 58 drought stricken counties.  
Yet, the TUCP as written by the Water Board is suspending standards  
that were too weak to begin with to protect fisheries, putting  
coastal, and Bay-Delta fisheries at immediate risk," she stated.

According to Barrigan-Parrilla, the Board's action, "Lowered Delta  
outflow for purpose of managing the ecosystems and salinity control -  
bad for fish, good for invasive species, helps storage by reducing how  
much water the projects spend from upstream reservoirs to keep salt  
out of the Delta."

RTD's protest focuses on the following:

The public interest in this matter concerns the protection of fish  
species, salinity control in the Delta, water supplies, and ecosystem  
conditions that prioritize a Bay-Delta estuary that continues to be  
fishable, swimmable, drinkable, and farmable in drought years as well  
as wet.

Droughts are recurrent and predictable weather patterns in California.  
Droughts are not emergencies, except when our water agencies fail to  
manage for their recurrence.

Current water quality objectives give a green light to the Department  
of Water Resources and the Bureau of Reclamation to gamble that each  
water year will be normal to wet: they prioritize upstream storage for  
exports to south of Delta storage, resulting in a “beggar-thy- 
neighbor” competition pitting against each other exports, salinity  
control, fish protection, and ecosystem-protective outflows. Dry-year  
south of Delta export demands put the Board in the difficult role of a  
veritable God Squad with immediate power over the Delta’s endangered  
fish.

This situation is preventable and state and federal agencies failed to  
prevent it.

Water rights attorney and C-WIN Board Member Mike Jackson warned of  
the tremendous environmental and economic damage that would result  
from approval of the Temporary Urgency Change Petitions.

"Evidently after the Bureau of Reclamation’s killing of 95% of the  
endangered winter-run salmon last year, the Federal government has  
decided to propose a much worse water plan for 2015," said Jackson.  
"It’s a much more complicated plan, but if it is approved by the  
California Water Board it may send both the endangered salmon and  
Delta smelt to extinction. We will find out soon if the Governor’s  
office intervenes with the Water Board to help finish off the fish.”

“Once again, Senator Feinstein (D-Westlands) favors big agribusinesses  
on the west side of the San Joaquin Valley over the economic and  
environmental needs of the people who live in the Bay-Delta Estuary,"  
said Jackson. "Commercial salmon fishing is a $1.5 billion economy,  
Delta farming a $5.2 billion economy, and of course there are the  
millions of people who live in communities surrounding the estuary.  
With this drought, we are poised to lose Delta smelt, Winter-run  
salmon, and steelhead as these fisheries are collapsing."

"Where is Senator Feinstein's concern for the people of the estuary?”  
Jackson asked.

Just blocks away, record low numbers of steelhead show...

The board meeting took place as just blocks away, the worst-ever run  
of steelhead continued to trickle into the American River,  
Sacramento's imperiled urban jewel.

The Nimbus Fish Hatchery in Rancho Cordova has trapped a total of only  
111 fish to date. In a good year, the hatchery would have already  
trapped thousands of steelhead.

The previous record low was 200 steelhead in the early 1990s, but this  
run looks like it will be well below that disastrous return. The peak  
of the run is over and increasingly fewer fish are expected to return  
to the hatchery while the ladder remains open.

During 2013 and early 2014, the Bureau of Reclamation drained Folsom  
to a record low level of 17 percent of capacity in order to export  
water to corporate agribusiness, Southern California water agencies  
and big oil companies. The Bureau did this in spite of it being a  
record drought year. Nimbus Dam releases were reduced to 500 cfs  
during most of the steelhead season last year.

“The steelhead died for a noble cause - almonds," quipped CSPA  
Executive Director Bill Jennings.

“The reason why American River steelhead are in collapse is the same  
reason why Delta smelt, longfin smelt, striped bass and other fish are  
down to less than 1 percent of their historic levels – overpumping of  
Delta water,” said Jennings.

For more information about the collapse of American River steelhead,  
go to:http://www.indybay.org/newsitems/2015/02/19/18768785.php
§A packed meeting
by Dan Bacher Saturday Feb 21st, 2015 6:20 PM

800_packed_meeting.jpg
original image ( 5184x3456)

The water board meeting was packed with fishermen, Delta residents and  
family farmers,, corporate agribusiness representatives, farmworkers  
and water agency officials. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Senator Jean Fuller
by Dan Bacher Saturday Feb 21st, 2015 6:20 PM

800_senator_fuller_1.jpg
original image ( 5184x3456)

Senator Jean Fuller (R-Bakersfield) speaks up for Kern County  
corporate agribusiness interests at the water board meeting in  
Sacramento. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Water Board
by Dan Bacher Saturday Feb 21st, 2015 6:20 PM

800_water_board_1.jpg
original image ( 5184x3456)

The State Water Resources Control Board hearing in Sacramento lasted  
for 12 hours. Photo by Dan Bacher.
§Farmworkers from the west side
by Dan Bacher Saturday Feb 21st, 2015 6:20 PM

800_farmworkers_get_visit...
original image ( 5184x3456)

The growers chartered buses filled with farmworkers from the west side  
of the San Joaquin Valley to attend the hearing. Here farmworkers with  
shirts proclaiming "Let Water Flow To People Not Fish" check in with  
Cal EPA building security. Photo by Dan Bacher.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: cspa_jennings_tucp_presentation.pdf_600_.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 65560 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 800_packed_meeting.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 348677 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment-0001.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 800_senator_fuller_1.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 244175 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment-0002.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 800_water_board_1.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 309560 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment-0003.jpg>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: 800_farmworkers_get_visitors_badges_1.jpg
Type: image/jpeg
Size: 282006 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20150223/33db5b5c/attachment-0004.jpg>