[env-trinity] Redding.com editorial: Editorial: If irrigators win, and salmon die, it will cost dearly

[Ara Azhderian]

I think the editorial misses the point.  This conflict isn’t about farmers versus fish.  It is about Reclamation and others mismanaging the water supplies available for fishery protection.  It is about Reclamation, as a result, creating a totally avoidable crisis.  Reclamation knew about this request months ago.  They could have planned to use water set aside for fishery protection under the Trinity River 2000 Record of Decision to legally satisfy this request.  They chose not to.  Instead, they chose to take even more water from the CVP, which is already struggling to meet its obligations.  They chose to further imperil listed species and waterfowl and people who rely upon that water for their daily needs, for power, for recreation, and for growing the healthy, safe, and affordable food that helps feed this nation.

Sent from my Verizon Wireless 4G LTE DROID


kierassociates at suddenlink.net wrote:

That's a helluva well-written editorial ! Kudos to the Record-Searchlight !

Bill
--
Kier Associates
Fisheries and Watershed Professionals
15 Junipero Serra Avenue
San Rafael, CA 94901-2319
(415) 721-7548
www.kierassociates.net<http://www.kierassociates.net>

---- Tom Stokely <tstokely at att.net> wrote:
> http://www.redding.com/news/2013/aug/12/if-irrigators-win-and-salmon-die-it-will-cost/
> Editorial: If irrigators win, and salmon die, it will cost dearly
> Posted August 12, 2013 at 6 p.m.
>
>
> Dry conditions are bad for farmers, but the publicity disaster might be even worse.
>
> San Joaquin Valley irrigators feel so squeezed by severe federal water cutbacks that they’re asking the federal courts to stop releases of extra water from Trinity Lake that aim to keep the lower Klamath River cool, flush out a fish-killing microbe, and ensure decent conditions for a bumper crop of chinook salmon.
>
> The extra releases, which the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation announced last week, begin today, but Westlands Water District and the San Luis & Delta-Mendota Water Authority are seeking an injunction. The lawyers argue that the likely impacts of releasing the water downstream instead of hoarding it in the reservoir are much larger than Reclamation acknowledges and need deeper study, and that the whole process doesn’t follow the Endangered Species Act.
>
> The bottom line is simple, though: The farmers think they need the water more than the fish do. From their perspective, it’s understandable. It’s precisely in times of scarcity that users fight most urgently for every drop of water.
>
> But in the long run, the worst thing that could happen to these big Central Valley Project contractors is for them to win.
>
> Suppose they convince a judge of legal flaws in Reclamation’s decision. Suppose the judge orders an emergency halt to the water surge. Suppose more than 100,000 king salmon wash up dead on the shores of the Klamath — of a disease the dam operators had a plan to prevent, a plan stopped by Big Corporate Ag’s lawyers.
>
> How’ll that look in the East Coast papers? How’ll that help farmers’ plea for relief from a “Congress Created Dust Bowl”? How’ll that win the trust of Northern Californians fearful that the “twin tunnels” through the Delta will suck rivers dry with no regard for the consequences?
>
> We’re talking hypotheticals, of course. Maybe everything would work out just fine.
>
> But the fact is Reclamation over the past decade has periodically released these extra slugs of Trinity water downstream in comparable conditions, and in each year they’ve worked — avoiding a fish kill like the nationally notorious disaster of 2002. And if “area of origin” rights mean anything, it’s that the Trinity’s water should be used first for the Trinity’s needs — not those 300 miles south.
>
> Reclamation’s doing the right thing in leaving enough water in the river for fish to thrive, despite the real costs. The Westlands lawsuit just confirms that down-state irrigators’ thirst, in a pinch, will be slaked at the North State’s expense. And if the suit succeeds and the fish suffer as the worst-case scenarios predict, a few thousand extra acre-feet of Trinity Water won’t be nearly enough to wash the stink of dead fish off the irrigators’ reputation.
>
>

_______________________________________________
env-trinity mailing list
env-trinity at velocipede.dcn.davis.ca.us
http://www2.dcn.org/mailman/listinfo/env-trinity
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20130813/385b6ccd/attachment.html>